What's the difference between scholarly and popular sources?

Answer

Sources are often categorized as "popular" or "scholarly" based on how they are produced and the intended readership. In your research you may use scholarly, popular, or both types of resources depending on the type of research that you are doing, your topic, and the requirements set by your professor.

Here are some of the characteristics that define these two types of sources:

Three Scholarly Journals: JAMA, Nature, and The Classic Review

Characteristics of Scholarly Sources

  • Publications often focus on a specific discipline or sub-discipline.
  • For books, publishers will often be scholarly such as a University Press.
  • Authors are typically scholars and/or researchers.
  • Works are written for faculty/researchers using technical terms and jargon.
  • Articles tend to be longer and focus on a very specific aspect of a topic.
  • Articles in journals can take several months or years to write, so they often do not cover very current topics.
  • Cited sources will be listed either throughout the work and/or at the end in a bibliography.
 
Three Magazines: Time Magazine, National Geographic, and The New Yorker
 
Characteristics of Popular Sources
  • Publications often focus on a variety of topics or within a larger discipline.
  • For books, publishers will often be ones that publish for general audiences.
  • Authors are typically staff writers or journalists.
  • Works are written for the general public.
  • Articles tend to be shorter in length and provide more general information.
  • Articles in magazines and newspapers can be written much more quickly than journals, so they can cover very current topics.
  • Cited sources are rarely listed within or at the end of an article. Sources may or may not be listed for book publications.
  • Last Updated Jun 04, 2024
  • Views 271
  • Answered By Johanna MacKay

FAQ Actions

Was this helpful? 0 0

Contact Us

Research Help Desk

Spring 2025 Hours 

Monday - Thursday: 10:00am-9:00pm

Friday: Librarians on call. Please ask at the Circulation Desk.

Sunday: 6:00pm-9:00pm

 

One-On-One Consultations

Schedule an appointment using our Research Help Request form.

You can also email your subject librarian to schedule an in-person or Zoom appointment.